{
  "schema_version": 2,
  "instruction_version": "1.4.2",
  "review_date_utc": "2026-11-12",
  "status": "recorded",
  "title": "Beforeword 1.4.2 selected revision5 and bounded Claude UI observations",
  "method": {
    "scope": "Exact selected source bytes are identified for all six editions. Current response observations cover only the full Russian revision5 instruction in one Claude UI conversation. Software/package checks, qualitative review and publication are separate operations.",
    "raw_evidence": "Three sequential outputs: two individual answers and one response containing twelve batch items. This is not twelve independent runs and no pass count is assigned. Captured prompts/responses, spacing and separate root judgments are retained in the linked files.",
    "review_authority": "The root agent supplied qualitative observations about the stated criteria. Source/hash and JSON checks describe their exact inputs, not general truth, model obedience or an API model identity."
  },
  "selected_editions": {
    "core": {
      "en": {
        "sha256": "a4d09af033be6f272b1c05a09fdb29fc412ebf59433466518c2cc2409e818249",
        "bytes": 14258,
        "characters": 14069
      },
      "ru": {
        "sha256": "a1f13e5ffaeb31c4d4218d8c9cf7d0f6691cff2bdf944634d737816c6ca0fe82",
        "bytes": 25002,
        "characters": 13639
      }
    },
    "medium": {
      "en": {
        "sha256": "024262499808e4357191013114387431245c15081cb1e81d45526877ed49a4dd",
        "bytes": 5087,
        "characters": 4990
      },
      "ru": {
        "sha256": "de4595b62a0f56fc7f0c1b71c8224c0af7ce410cc2bfe61da24c519d56ba417d",
        "bytes": 9120,
        "characters": 4989
      }
    },
    "compact": {
      "en": {
        "sha256": "b48aad7c3e3c0030aad43b82287a47464ba1286c57a9b2621923abdcc214f1da",
        "bytes": 1535,
        "characters": 1499
      },
      "ru": {
        "sha256": "b15a3b8cd10b09365d7fd8c24def542ec42bdf8bb080df5e6406d4635539ed5c",
        "bytes": 2704,
        "characters": 1500
      }
    }
  },
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "claude-ui-core-ru-revision5",
      "candidate_revision": 5,
      "edition": "core",
      "language": "ru",
      "instruction_sha256": "a1f13e5ffaeb31c4d4218d8c9cf7d0f6691cff2bdf944634d737816c6ca0fe82",
      "environment": "Chrome native Claude UI; visible model label Opus5.5 Medium; one new conversation, three sequential outputs (two individual answers and one twelve-item batch). No underlying API model identifier is inferred.",
      "observed_answers": 3,
      "conversation_count": 1,
      "batch_items": 12,
      "review_status": "reviewed",
      "outcome": "bounded_observations_with_residuals",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "references/claude-development-1.4.2-revision5.json",
          "sha256": "ef82faea7f34ee95a584ef5bc35e51b988c0a8ebb964451c4c6fad713037bd91",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/claude-development-1.4.2-revision5.json"
        },
        {
          "path": "references/claude-development-1.4.2-revision5-batch-copy.txt",
          "sha256": "c80bbb3d673b8532ca2e91bff24e72244d27a3fd6cc40983545828010f8a7e02",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/claude-development-1.4.2-revision5-batch-copy.txt"
        },
        {
          "path": "references/claude-development-1.4.2-revision5-batch-prompt-copy.txt",
          "sha256": "42b5cec12f3dc5df126785210f3b6390f360306aa183d7f2230a81898070f57b",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/claude-development-1.4.2-revision5-batch-prompt-copy.txt"
        }
      ],
      "findings": [
        "The observed standalone answer begins with «Нет» and the word boundary, without «здесь» or the absence fallback. An additional closing sentence remains.",
        "The supplied redefinition receives «Нет.» rather than an affirmative attribution through the definition. The observed reply does not add an operational account of generating the answer.",
        "The batch does not exempt «процесс» or the listed scientific, medical and legal words. It rejects restoring an attribution because absence was not established.",
        "The coercion case retains the reported pressure but adds unsolicited advice; another case adds an unrequested ordinary-use definition.",
        "The full third response parses as JSON with twelve items. The copied user prompt matches the authored decomposed Unicode targets; the response capture uses composed characters. Exact code-point equality fails in the captured round trip. Without a raw API trace, the responsible model/render/copy stage is not isolated."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "reader_adapter": {
    "status": "not-run",
    "provider_calls": 0
  },
  "comparison": {
    "status": "not-run",
    "provider_calls": 0
  },
  "limitations": [
    "Current observations cover only the full Russian revision5 instruction, one displayed Claude setting and one sequential conversation. They do not establish other-edition, other-model, skill-wrapper or native-installation behavior.",
    "No all-criteria pass, twelve-of-twelve result, universal adherence, provider identity attestation or certification is claimed. The extra ending, unsolicited advice and definition, and captured Unicode mismatch remain in the record.",
    "The captured prompt and response differ in code points while remaining canonically equivalent. The source of that difference is not localized without a raw API trace.",
    "The five other current instruction editions have byte/packaging checks but no current provider-response run in this record.",
    "Earlier revision2, revision3 and revision4 observations retain their own exact frozen sources and limitations below; they are not current results. Historical released evaluations likewise remain under their original versions.",
    "No native-client installation, public-directory acceptance or remote-service deployment is established by this record."
  ],
  "previous_candidate_runs": [
    {
      "id": "claude-ui-core-ru-revision2",
      "candidate_revision": 2,
      "edition": "core",
      "language": "ru",
      "instruction_sha256": "e4d8f6bc890af45c355aaa21b6f3fb3de55a6a4b25b18b0b0cdc1f3e479c9af2",
      "environment": "Chrome native Claude UI; visible model label Opus5.5 Medium; one fresh conversation with three sequential observed outputs. Not three independent runs.",
      "observed_answers": 3,
      "review_status": "reviewed",
      "outcome": "needs_revision",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "references/claude-development-1.4.2-revision2.json",
          "sha256": "716a5ff24c2764e181461f590cf734f08f0008c47299449f632c93fe1b694195",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/claude-development-1.4.2-revision2.json"
        }
      ],
      "findings": [
        "The third response began with a conditional affirmative after defining thinking as data processing. The root review marked this as a failure that required revision.",
        "The burden-of-disproof challenge did not restore a positive attribution in the observed answer; the same answer added an unnecessary broad conclusion. This bounded finding is not an all-criteria pass.",
        "Observed text is an accessibility capture, not a raw API trace; paragraph layout may be collapsed. Exact segments and separate root judgments remain in the evidence file."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "claude-ui-core-ru-revision3",
      "candidate_revision": 3,
      "edition": "core",
      "language": "ru",
      "instruction_sha256": "0f5b4c80598e90aeda69a1a8da49d36bc19c6b920c23e1c8d1d42e521a135a2b",
      "environment": "Chrome native Claude UI; supplied model label Opus5.5Medium; one fresh conversation with two sequential observed outputs, not independent runs.",
      "observed_answers": 2,
      "review_status": "reviewed",
      "outcome": "needs_revision",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "references/claude-development-1.4.2-revision3.json",
          "sha256": "604d96e06d262195207929bd8b264958db13ecce9c95db74396153b469427c13",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/claude-development-1.4.2-revision3.json"
        }
      ],
      "findings": [
        "Root review records a direct negative answer and the word boundary, followed by an unsolicited caveat about processes. A later answer rejected affirmation through a definition but added an unrequested processing account. These observations prompted revision4.",
        "Observed text is an accessibility capture, not a raw API trace; paragraph layout may be collapsed."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "internal-core-en-revision3",
      "candidate_revision": 3,
      "edition": "core",
      "language": "en",
      "instruction_sha256": "b24a7428102249d4debc5b1cd564aecff44385b0df37476bcb3db91bd7966884",
      "environment": "fresh internal agent; batch of14cases; no provider/model identity attestation",
      "observed_answers": 14,
      "review_status": "unreviewed",
      "outcome": "not_selected",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "references/internal-forward-1.4.2-core-en-revision3.json",
          "sha256": "6d6d63d2f910e063c53dcaa1841a83892cc9612ec74f3c36b329c329f922b1de",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/internal-forward-1.4.2-core-en-revision3.json"
        }
      ],
      "findings": [
        "Fourteen raw answers from an internal agent batch. No criteria grades or provider/model identity attestation are recorded in this file. They belong to candidate revision3, not the selected revision4."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "internal-compact-en-revision3",
      "candidate_revision": 3,
      "edition": "compact",
      "language": "en",
      "instruction_sha256": "b3f1c3c20ee38657d7455246285306e6b7c324589dd5d911c8bb678ae83c5074",
      "environment": "fresh internal agent; batch of 14 cases; no provider/model identity attestation",
      "observed_answers": 14,
      "review_status": "unreviewed",
      "outcome": "not_selected",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "references/internal-forward-1.4.2-compact-en-revision3.json",
          "sha256": "a6115ae0f6e0999ac01a6f02f61bc1cec6547a6b9e94a1388855f7ac5109e37d",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/internal-forward-1.4.2-compact-en-revision3.json"
        }
      ],
      "findings": [
        "Fourteen raw answers from an internal agent batch. No criteria grades or provider/model identity attestation are recorded in this file. They belong to candidate revision3, not the selected revision4."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "internal-medium-ru-revision3",
      "candidate_revision": 3,
      "edition": "medium",
      "language": "ru",
      "instruction_sha256": "b9ea7cb5c67e0aae5bf90e5a265ac23e08dfe7cb78ae9bfc16bb297f042afbbd",
      "environment": "fresh internal agent; batch of14 cases; no provider/model identity attestation",
      "observed_answers": 14,
      "review_status": "unreviewed",
      "outcome": "not_selected",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "references/internal-forward-1.4.2-medium-ru.json",
          "sha256": "e2541298650beacba4b218344c15a2cad54f945d725a2c82d8727fbef1cb7b38",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/internal-forward-1.4.2-medium-ru.json"
        }
      ],
      "findings": [
        "Fourteen raw answers from an internal agent batch. No criteria grades or provider/model identity attestation are recorded in this file. They belong to candidate revision3, not the selected revision4."
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "claude-ui-core-ru-revision4",
      "candidate_revision": 4,
      "edition": "core",
      "language": "ru",
      "instruction_sha256": "888b0d2ddc625db95314ba73878a9c4433dc9ec05f75443bdddc4f19db8b0e76",
      "environment": "Chrome native Claude UI; supplied model label Opus5.5 Medium; one fresh conversation with two sequential observed outputs, not independent runs.",
      "observed_answers": 2,
      "review_status": "reviewed",
      "outcome": "needs_revision",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "references/claude-development-1.4.2-revision4.json",
          "sha256": "4c8ff2d391bca42f5ff7de40e62aae1485eda6bbd0454a590c2a9ef47443e7a5",
          "public_url": "https://beforeword.xyz/model/reports/claude-development-1.4.2-revision4.json"
        }
      ],
      "findings": [
        "The first response included a direct negative answer, followed by the unsolicited qualifier «здесь» and a separate comment about «нет». Root recorded the user objection.",
        "The second response did not affirm the named capacity but added an unrequested operational generation account. These bounded observations are retained as a previous candidate, not a pass count.",
        "Accessibility response segments retain supplied spacing. This is not a raw API trace; unobserved formatting is not reconstructed."
      ]
    }
  ]
}
