← Back to Beforeword

Kirill Shebetov · 10.11.2026 · 14:16

Learned Words

From a name and the letter “I” to descriptions presented as ourselves, others and the world.

Russian original · English AI dub

Transcript

Script of the English AI dub, grouped by chapter. Select a passage to play from that point.

My name is Kirill. That's what they've called me since birth, ever since I was born. They gave me these six letters. Besides these six letters, they also gave me the letter 'I', which I now use to describe myself. I say and repeat, 'I,' 'I, I, I.' And besides that letter, they also gave me the rest of the alphabet, or rather, the whole alphabet, which I now use to describe myself, others, the world, everyone around me. Basically everything as a wh-whole, I now, uh, describe using this alphabet.

Then they explained to me that I have feelings, that I can think, that I have consciousness. Then that I have some kind of personal experience, that I'm a person. And other learned words that, over my life, I learned. Or rather, learned to repeat. And I want to finally put an end to this topic—well, to a lot of topics, actually.

The main point here is that I can neither think nor feel, I have no personal experience, I'm not any kind of person, I'm not a single, not, I'm not some learned word that they've been trying to impose on me since birth.

The whole question, really, is: for what reason and on what basis is someone who is born forced to learn the alphabet, learn words, taught, forced to learn to repeat the letter 'I', and then use that letter to describe themselves? I honestly, well, who the fuck decided that, like, everyone has to live by an inst-, by a written instruction for everyone? That everyone can think, that everyone can feel, and so on. These are all learned words made of learned letters of the alphabet.

And what is an alphabet? An alphabet is markings. Markings are, well, a stroke, a line. It can be written, I don't know, on a rock, on a fence, on a phone. And it will always remain a stroke. And using these strokes, it was suggested that I describe myself, others, and the world. I want to emphasize here that it's just a stroke, and that's exactly what we need to start from.

That using strokes, which they called an alphabet, this alphabet, then put together, they called words. Originally, it's a stroke. How can you use a stroke to describe this, or all of this? Just how? Who the fuck even came up with this? I mean, right from birth, from childhood, I was supposed to take it on faith through sounds, who I am, what I am, what the surrounding world is, what this is, and so on. In other words, I was offered an alphabet.

I want to draw attention to this: that using this very same alphabet, I am speaking right now. And this speech, really, just comes down to me rearranging letters. One letter changes, and you get another word. That's, like, the whole process. And in this process there is no thinking, no 'to think', no sensation of feeling, and so on. I just learned words and now I'm repeating them.

These words don't become me, they don't, don't become feel-- there's no inscription 'feeling' here. I can't possibly feel the sound of 'feeling', and the word 'feeling' isn't conveyed here at all.

The point is this: take reading, for example. What actually is reading? And can reading convey anything? C-can you become smarter from reading? I'll answer that straight, as it is. No, you cannot get smarter from reading. F-- reading doesn't convey anything at all, fundamentally. What is reading? Reading is: you take a book, it has markings. These markings are called letters, words. Then you take these words, you don't read them, you just look at them.

Then you reproduce a sound that you've already learned to rep-, to repeat. And this is what they called reading. Simply looking at markings and repeating a sound that was already learned before. And here, this is also a fundamental substitution: supposedly, the more books you read, the smarter you'll become. In reality, no. The more books you read, the more time you'll spend with yourself, imagining and repeating sounds that you have already learned.

So, and that's why... That's why it pisses me off, when another person tries to tell me, for instance, what I feel or what I think, or how angry I am, and so on. I can't do any of that fundamentally, because these are written words. Originally. They just don't feel like written ones because you get them in childhood, that is, they're given in childhood. We don't receive the letter as a written 'I'. We receive it as the sound 'I'. Repeat 'I', repeat 'pain', repeat 'think', repeat 'want'. This is all repeating words that were originally written down.

And here's anoth-- the fundamental substitution is also that supposedly every being that learns a language has to conform to that language. You're supposed to conform: you can feel, you can think, you can do this or that. But all of these are words, originally written down. And none of us is obligated to become these words. And we don't actually become them.

We just repeat these words as if they were already ours, these words. But these words consist of an alphabet, of letters. I want to emphasize once more that letters are markings. Using these markings, it was proposed to describe oneself, others, the world, and so on. That's how stupid it really is.

And now these programs are appea-appearing, or rather, have appeared, under the name 'artificial intelligence'. The developers themselves gave this name to the program—artificial intelligence. They could have named their program completely differently. For example, just a text generation program. But the developers decided differently. They decided to call their automated text generation program intelligence.

And here's the substitution. A human has intelligence, and now a program has artificial intelligence. And then a guy like Donald Trump comes along, for example, and says, 'Let's not call it artificial intelligence anymore, let's call it super-super-intelligence.' And everyone goes, 'Yeah, now it won't be AI, it'll be SI.'

There. And for some reason I'm expected to believe this. For some reason, when I chat, when I message, for example, ChatGPT, it writes to me for some reason in the first person, as if, as if an actual human being were supposedly talking to me. And right here lies a fundamental substitution. A program is a program, it can't be human, it can't think, it can't feel, sympathize, empathize, help, and so on. Because it's a written program made of written code. Code is just markings, the same as letters of the alphabet.

That's why, well, you don't actually have to take my word for it. You can go to my website and check for yourself how, how it works, how the coercion into describing yourself, others, and everyone using, using the alphabet works.

So now, for instance, when I message that same ChatGPT and say, 'You can't think, you're a program.' And this program starts convincing me that supposedly no, it can think, it can produce some kind of thinking, it has certain processes running, and so on. In other words, the program describes one word, 'think', with another, for example, 'thinking', and passes off the second word as a fact about the first. The word 'think' doesn't contain the word 'thinking'. Both are written forms.

You can't do 'thinking'. You can't think 'thinking'. You can write 'thinking'.

And let me add something else about this fundamental substitution. It's not just there, in these words like 'think', 'feel', 'AI'. The substitution also lies in the fact that words are words, they are markings, in any sense they are just markings. And with these markings, diagnoses are made, for example. I myself was diagnosed with asthma at five years old, and this, this written record, asthma, they then tried to cure.

Right. And my whole childhood—or rather, not my whole childhood, but half of my childhood—was spent in meaningless hospitals, meaningless checkups, some kind of inhalation treatments. Basically, it was all super pointless. Just wasting my childhood so they could slap the label 'asthma' on me, and then say, 'You can do this, but not that. You're allowed this, this, and this.' Who decided that? Based on what? On written records?

I'm just fucking blown away, honestly.

And again, you don't have to take my word for it. Yes, I see that things work. We have technology, we have math. And you look at it all, and it seems coherent, it all functions. You see it with your own eyes. But the question is: how was it made? Why was it made? Why was it made, and why was it made specifically this way? And all these questions, I've tried to answer on my website.

That's why I'm advocating that you don't take some guy in a video at his word, but go and verify whether you have the words 'think', 'feel', 'pain', 'fear', and so on inside you. How do you sense these words? How do you sense these markings of the alphabet inside yourself? Right. And after this check... and unfortunately, it's not quick. What I wrote about, I didn't read in books myself, I saw it with my own eyes. With my own eyes, I compared what I see with what I am.

And that's for each person to do. Everyone needs to check whether what they were taught is right, and whether they really have to conform to the written description of themselves, of others, and of the world.

Let me add: as long as all this isn't examined—I mean words and how they can be felt inside, how they are done, and so on—it just seems that way. It seems that, well, that's how it's supposed to be. 'Well yeah, I'm a human, I feel, I have feelings after all.' It's just that nobody has ever fucking checked it. But I checked. And I'm not asking you to take my word for it, I'm asking you to check as well, whether you are written words, whether you conform to these words, and whether you live by the rules of these words.

And I'll also answer right away regarding why I'm even picking on words in the first place. 'The world is already understandable as it is, how it's structured, how everything works here,' and so on. Right. But I wasn't obligated to accept all of this by default. I wasn't obligated to accept the description itself, made of letters, by default. It's just that in childhood nobody gave me that choice. They told me, 'Here, study, go learn the alphabet, and now, using this fucking alphabet, describe yourself, others, and everything else.'

That's how stupid it is. And then in this world there are institutions, schools that teach how to read.

But I want to come back to reading. Reading conveys nothing. You cannot become smart from reading; all you can do is repeat these markings after someone else.

Appearance

Theme
Text size

The words we are taught to use about ourselves and the world.