← Animated films13 of 16

They Gave Me a Name and Said, “This Is You”

Kirill is made to sign “I am bad.” Later the signature is held up as his own admission. Anyone can see the words he wrote. The pressure he was under leaves no trace on the sheet.

What the signature leaves out

The signature tells us who wrote “I am bad.” Leave out the threat of punishment and the promise of a diploma, and someone else’s judgment can pass for Kirill’s own admission. That is how the signed sheet comes to be used against him.

First the adults decide how to mark a piece of schoolwork. Then the principal tells Kirill to put their judgment in the first person, write “I am bad” and sign it. The words in Kirill’s voice have been chosen before he starts writing.

About the ending

When Kirill objects, he is reminded that he wrote the words himself. He did write them. Whose judgment was it, and who required him to repeat it?

Appearance

Theme
Text size

The words we are taught to use about ourselves and the world.