In plain English

What gets added when you read?

Beforeword examines learned descriptions replacing ourselves, others and the world through three examples: the message “No.”, a demand to regard oneself as “human”, and a formula. Each shows what is added and when it becomes a requirement.

01 · Example

From a reply to a description of someone

An example written for this page

Written message

No.

Added reading

He’s angry.

The second line adds “He’s” and “angry.” Neither appears in “No.” Other messages could help explain this reading. For instance, adding “I’m angry about yesterday’s conversation” would let the explanation point to the word “angry.” That would be additional text in the example.

“He’s angry” describes anger; the description does not become anger. “Description” and “reading” are also written here: they label the steps used to compare the two lines.

02 · Example

Being told to see yourself as “human”

An example written for this page

An account of being taught

I was taught to say, “I am human.”

A demand

You must think of yourself as human.

The first line reports being taught a phrase. The second says you must see yourself as “human”. Adding “because that’s what you were taught” uses the teaching to justify the demand. What words were taught? What is now required? What rule is offered to justify that requirement?

If the account says “I was forced,” that wording stays in the examination. An account of coercion cannot be replaced with an account of free choice. Here, “teaching,” “demand,” and “coercion” are words used to explain the lines. Neither they nor the written word “human” become who or what they describe.

03 · Example

From symbols to an explanation of a formula

An example written for this page · step by step
  1. Starting expression

    2 + two
  2. The substitution used here

    “two” → “2”
  3. Written using the rule for addition

    2 + 2 = 4

The example replaces “two” with “2” and reads “+” as integer addition. It then calls “4” the result. “Number,” “addition,” and “result” explain how the expressions are connected; these explanations are also written.

Adding “checked by a program” would continue the description. Code, conditions, and a recorded result could explain that phrase in more detail. Neither the phrase nor its detailed explanation becomes the check it describes.

Three questions for an example of your own

  1. What is written?

    Quote the original line without changing it.

  2. What does the reading add?

    Place the definition, judgment, or demand beside it.

  3. What supports the addition?

    Show the relevant passage, rule, or step and how it was used.

This is what “the boundary of written form” means here: an explanation remains written; it does not become what it names. “Boundary,” “rule,” and “beforeword,” along with these three questions, are part of this explanation too.

Six more examples

Open any example to read the explanation.

01Letters, “I” and “my feelings”
A mark. A letter. A reading.

01 · A mark

02 · A letter

03 · A reading

“that’s me”

A made-up example. The second panel adds strokes to form “I”. The last repeats the letter and adds “that’s me”. Neither the letter nor the explanation becomes what it describes. The captions are writing too.

The third panel adds “that’s me” beside the letter. “That” invites a connection between the writing and oneself. The caption shows this reading, but neither the caption nor the letter becomes the one it names.

The same letters in a different order

An English version of the letter example

Original text

I feel pain

For comparison

I feel ipna

“pain” and “ipna” contain the same letters in a different order. The rest of the sentence stays the same.

“ipna” can be read as “the letters of ‘pain’ rearranged”. This adds an explanation. The rearrangement is shown above; explaining how it is read adds more writing.

From reading to self-description

Added when reading

this describes me

Proposed explanation

that is what I was taught

First, “pain” is presented as a word someone has been taught to read. Then “this describes me” is added to “I feel pain”. With “me”, the sentence is presented as a description of oneself.

The phrase “that is what I was taught” adds an explanation about learning to read the sentence this way. Neither the sentence, the account of learning, nor this explanation becomes what it describes.

From “feelings” to “my feelings”

The example continues

A label

feelings

Adding “my”

my feelings

A demand

Name what you feel

“my” has been added to “feelings”. With this addition, the label is presented as a description of oneself.

The next line demands a label. The answer is expected to use other learned words: “sadness”, “joy”, “shame”, “fear”, “pain”, “love”, “pride”. The chosen word must then be explained through further words.

You were taught the word “feelings”. Why must that word be treated as your feelings? Why must you describe yourself using other words you were taught?

The answer “I feel fear” continues the text. Explaining why “fear” was chosen adds more writing. Neither the label, “my”, the demand, nor this explanation becomes what is described.

Being taught to say a name

In a scene written for this page, a child is told, “Repeat your name.” Here, “told” and “repeat” describe learning to speak. This account does not establish that the child was shown letters. The account of speech and the written name can be compared, but the written word “voice” does not play back a voice.

Later in the example comes “that’s my name.” The added “my” invites the learned label to be read as referring to oneself. If “you must call yourself that” follows, the demand is part of the examination too. Explaining how the words were taught does not remove the demand.

02Sound, repetition and “you understood me”

Two figures, with lines between them. The captions invite you to read the drawing as a conversation. No audio is played.

An illustrative diagram · three frames

01 / 03From mouth to ear

Two figures facing each otherTwo outlined profiles, with their mouths and ears marked. Five strokes of different heights form a wave pattern directed from the left figure towards the right.

The line from the left figure towards the right is presented as “one speaks, the other hears”.

02 / 03The pattern repeats

A suggested explanation

“taught to recognise this sound”

Two figures facing each otherThe same profiles. The same five-stroke pattern is directed from the right figure towards the left. The order of the strokes is unchanged.

The same wave pattern points in the opposite direction. The caption presents this as “repetition”.

03 / 03An added reading

Two figures facing each otherThe same profiles and two identical five-stroke patterns. A written caption is added below.

The depicted repetition gets another caption:

you understood me

Why read repetition as understanding?

The same diagram could instead be captioned “not taught to recognise this sound”. The drawing stays the same; the written explanation changes. Neither caption becomes the learning or recognition it describes.

The wave pattern stands for sound in this diagram. The words “sound”, “hears”, “repeats” and “understands” are written explanations. Neither the line, the caption, nor this explanation becomes what it describes.

03A command, a movement and “the dog understood”

Here, the figures are described as a “person” and a “dog”, and the wave pattern stands for sound. No audio is played.

An illustrative diagram · three frames

01 / 03A word is added to the wave

An illustrative caption

“sit”

A diagram with figures described as a person and a dogTwo outlined figures described as a person and a dog. A wave pattern between them points from the person towards the dog.

The wave is captioned “sit”. The caption invites you to read the drawing as a spoken command.

02 / 03The figure changes posture

A suggested explanation

“the dog was taught to sit on command”

A diagram with figures described as a person and a dogThe same outlined person and a dog in a seated pose. A caption about learning is shown above.

In this frame, the figure is drawn seated. A caption about learning has been added; the drawing itself does not show how that learning took place.

03 / 03One drawing, two captions

A diagram with figures described as a person and a dogThe same outlined person and the same seated dog. Written explanations are compared below the drawing.

Compare the two explanations. The drawing stays the same; the words below it change.

Compare captions

the dog understood the command

The figure is drawn in different postures in two frames. The caption adds “understood” and proposes understanding the command as an explanation of the difference.

this is a learned response

“Learned response” offers another explanation for the same drawing. This explanation is also written.

What do “understood” and “learned response” add to the same drawing?

“Person”, “dog”, “command”, “learning” and this explanation are written forms. The captions, the diagram and this explanation do not become what they describe.

04“Life is a process”: what does a definition add?
An example written for this page

Question

What is life?

Suggested definition

Life is a process.

“Process” is added to explain “life.” The word “is” connects them in a definition. Explaining “process” through “change” and “time” would extend that definition with more words. Neither the definition nor its continuation becomes the life it names.

If “organism,” “system,” or “virus” is added, each addition needs examining where it appears: what is it being used to name, and how is it connected to the question? Beginning with “life is a word” does not do this work for the rest of the answer.

“The word does not create life” would introduce a claim about creation. The step examined here is how a written definition is read as what it names. This explanation also remains written.

05From marking an answer to refusing a place
An example written for this page · three entries
  1. An assessment of the answer

    Incorrect answer.
  2. A description of the person who answered

    Unable to learn.
  3. A proposed decision

    Refuse the student a place.

The second entry adds a description of ability to the assessment of an answer. The third adds a decision. Explaining these steps requires the tasks, answers, and assessment rules: what condition was applied first to the answer, then to the person who wrote it? Why is that condition used to justify the refusal?

“Rule” here names the suggested condition. Its wording allows the decision to be examined, but does not become ability, teaching, or refusal. The same applies to “evidence,” “doctor,” or “court” if they are added to the explanation.

06“I understand” under “human” and “AI” labels
Same words. Different labels.

human

I understand

AI

I understand

A made-up example. The words are identical. The labels invite different readings. Those labels are writing too.

Both lines say “I understand”. The labels “human” and “AI” name who or what the line is attributed to. If the labels were removed, those names would disappear from the example; the wording “I understand” would stay the same.

A task, an answer, and a rule for assessing it could be added. This would show why the answer was called “understanding” under that rule. The assessment does not become understanding. Neither matching lines nor different labels alone establish matching or different inner states; “state” in this explanation is also written.

32 questions by topic

Each question begins with a specific example. The answer examines the explanation offered there: what it adds, what supports it and what remains unresolved. Choose a topic or search for a question.

Words and reading

What is life?
A definition written for this example

Word to explain

life

Added definition

Life is a process.

“Life is a process” explains one word through another. For the definition to help, it needs to specify the kind of process and the criteria for calling it life. Otherwise, one familiar word has simply been replaced with another.

A biological definition can be examined alongside its criteria and examples of how they apply. That makes it possible to see why a case fits and where a disagreement arises. It explains the word’s use without becoming the life it describes.

Why must I identify with a word I was taught?
Two instructions written for this example

Entry requested

Write your name here.

Identification required

You must accept this name as who you are.

Being taught a word does not by itself create a duty to accept it as who you are. In this example, entering a name on a form becomes a demand to identify with it. That demand needs reasons of its own; repeating the familiar name does not supply them.

Beforeword proposes reconsidering demands to learn, repeat, understand and accept descriptions. This should not depend on first naming a refusal, explaining it or offering a replacement description of oneself. Access to language remains an opportunity; it does not establish compulsory participation.

If coercion is reported, preserve the exact demand and the consequences described. Repetition alone does not establish agreement, and silence does not automatically establish either agreement or refusal.

Why am I required to read and understand?
An example requirement and assessment

Requirement

You must read this and show that you understand.

Assessment

Understands.

Being able to read, completing a task and being required to participate are different questions. The example first demands reading and a demonstration of understanding, then assigns “understands.” Assessing that result needs the actual response and a criterion: what was tested?

Beforeword proposes allowing a demand to read, understand or respond to be withdrawn without first requiring proof of refusal. Someone may want to learn; the aim is to make learning available without turning that opportunity into an obligation.

If reading is tied to a grade, access or a penalty, those conditions belong in the analysis. Calling them a rule does not explain them: its wording, application and the grounds for the demand need to be stated.

What is the boundary of written form?
One word explained through another

First word

number

Added explanation

It is a quantity.

The example explains “number” through “quantity.” The new word can clarify the intended use, especially with a rule and an example. It remains an addition to the definition.

The boundary is straightforward: a written explanation does not become what it explains. This does not make definitions useless or require an endless explanation of them. An explanation can stop when the particular task is complete while keeping writing distinct from what it describes.

What about the word “difference”?
Two lines to compare

Reply

No.

Added reading

They’re angry.

“Difference” is also a word. Here it refers to a particular comparison: the first line contains only “No.” The second adds “They’re” and “angry.” The two lines can be compared to check that addition.

There are two questions: whether the records match and what supports reading the reply as anger. Comparing the writing answers the first. The second needs context or other relevant evidence. The distinction is useful because it identifies those separate tasks.

Is saying “it’s a word” enough?
An answer written for this example

Opening

Life is a word.

Continuation

It is a system that sustains itself.

The opening points to “life” as a word. The next sentence adds “system” and “sustains itself”, then uses them to describe life. The first sentence has not explained those additions.

The explanation needs to address them where they appear. “System” introduces a category; “sustains itself” assigns an activity within that description. A useful answer can show how the terms are being connected. Naming a discipline, or ending with “this is writing too”, does not replace that step.

Does the same text mean the same reading?
Same reply, different labels

human

No.

AI

No.

The letters and punctuation in the two replies match. The labels “human” and “AI” are the parts that change. Here, “match” describes the comparison of the two written replies; the labels add ways to read them.

“They were read in the same way” would be another statement beside these lines. To explain it, show which replies, paraphrases or other records were compared and how. “Same reading” would then describe that comparison. Repeating the letters has not supplied the reading described by the added statement.

Isn’t beforeword writing too?
The two lines being compared

Reply

No.

Added reading

He’s angry.

The grounds should be shown rather than replaced by the name Beforeword. The two lines support a narrow conclusion that can be checked: “He’s angry” has been added to “No.” That depends on a visible comparison, not trust in the project.

The further claim that the person is angry needs more than those lines. Earlier messages or the participant’s explanation could be added and assessed. The same questions apply to a Beforeword answer: what is being compared, and which conclusion does that comparison support?

Why does AI write “I understand”?
Changing the voice does not remove the claim

First person

I understand.

Impersonal wording

Understanding occurred.

“I understand” presents an AI response as a speaker’s report of understanding. That form of speech does not itself establish the state it names. “Understanding occurred” removes the pronoun but keeps the claim.

Beforeword explanations instead identify the work done: for example, “The text says…” followed by the passage and an account of its reading. That makes the response easier to check. First-person wording remains in exact quotations, translations and requested drafts where the voice being reproduced is clear.

How can a short answer keep this boundary clear?
Answer and added claim

Request

Add 2 and 2.

Answer

4

Further claim

This proves understanding.

“4” is enough to answer “Add 2 and 2.” That task does not need a long introduction to Beforeword. The addition rule and its application can be shown if needed.

Adding “This proves understanding” adds a description to the result. Neither the calculation result nor the new sentence becomes what is called “understanding”. The same applies to translation or code: completing a task does not turn its result into the added name.

About ourselves

Who am I?
A description written for this example

Written word

I

Added description

I am a teacher.

A name or occupation offers a description someone can use. In this example, “a teacher” is added to “I.” An age, biography and other details would extend that description.

Beforeword asks why someone should be required to accept a description as who they are. Words can have a well-supported connection to a person without becoming that person. A particular description and its use can be discussed without demanding another final definition in its place.

What about my feelings?
A scene and its written continuation

Description given

You’re afraid.

Description repeated

I’m afraid.

Further claim

I know what I feel.

“I’m afraid” reports a feeling without becoming the feeling itself. That distinction does not dismiss the person’s report. It lets us consider the experience, its name and how the name was introduced separately.

In the constructed scene, “You’re afraid” is followed by the child’s “I’m afraid.” The familiar description is now used about oneself. Further details, such as a racing heart or tight throat, may explain its use. “I know what I feel” adds a claim of knowledge; it can be examined without replacing the person’s own account.

How do we read someone else’s emotions?
Three captions written for this example

Detail described

Tears.

One explanation

She is sad.

Another explanation

Tears of joy.

No photograph is shown in this example.

No photograph is supplied here, only possible captions. “Tears” names a detail; “She is sad” and “Tears of joy” offer different explanations. Comparing them needs the image and the information supporting each reading.

The move from “No.” to “He’s angry” raises the same question in a conversation. Earlier messages or the participant’s own account may help explain the reply. Show that connection while keeping the message and the emotion attributed to it separate.

What is love?
A message and two added statements

Message

I miss you.

Added name

This is love.

Further claim

We belong together.

The example reads “I miss you” as love, then adds “We belong together.” Each step makes a further claim about the relationship. The conversation, actions and circumstances offered as grounds matter; changing the label alone does not establish the connection.

An account of care or closeness can explain what is being called love. It remains an account of the relationship. It does not automatically establish another person’s feelings or an obligation to belong together.

What is consciousness?
Two statements written for this example

First statement

I am aware of myself.

Added description

This describes my consciousness.

The example explains “I am aware of myself” through the term “consciousness.” The term places the report under a concept. A useful explanation specifies how that concept is being used and what it adds to the first sentence.

A personal report, a test result and an assessment are distinct records. Calling a result “evidence of consciousness” adds a description; neither the description nor the result becomes what is named.

What does it mean to understand?
A claim, a task and an assessment

First statement

I understand.

Task

Explain it in your own words.

Assessment of the next answer

Now it is clear that they understand.

A task and a new answer can be placed between “I understand” and an assessment of understanding. This example asks for an explanation in different words. The next answer and the marking criteria could then be shown: which parts counted as an explanation, and why was that called “understanding”?

“Your own words” needs specific conditions too. Is a paraphrase allowed? Which words must change, and what must be preserved? Those conditions explain the assessment of the answer. The assessment remains a written account of understanding. Adding “human” or “AI” describes the writer; it does not change that boundary for the task, reply or explanation.

What is the meaning of life?
One possible answer written for this example

Question

What is the meaning of life?

Answer offered

The purpose of life is love.

“The purpose of life is love” offers a purpose. It is a proposal about how to live, so it can be discussed through its reasons, who offers it and whether someone wants to adopt it.

“Create” or “be happy” would offer other directions. Choosing among them is a further question; the wording does not settle it for the reader. An answer about life does not become that life or make its proposed purpose compulsory.

Do we have free will?
Two descriptions of a decision

One description

I chose.

Another description

It was inevitable.

“I chose” and “It was inevitable” explain a decision differently. Comparing them needs a particular case: what happened, which conditions are described and what supports a claim that another outcome was possible or impossible.

The words “choice” or “fate” do not complete that argument. Beforeword helps identify the added explanation and examine its connection to the case. The occurrence of “choice” alone does not settle the general question of free will.

Is AI conscious?
One example AI reply, two labels

Reply

I feel.

One label

Real feeling.

Another label

Imitation.

The reply “I feel” remains writing. “Conscious”, “real feeling” and “imitation” are further descriptions. None of these descriptions becomes what it names. Withdrawing an attribution does not require proving that what was attributed is absent.

A test can state its task, response and assessment rule. Calling its result “consciousness” adds a name; neither the result, the name nor its explanation becomes what is named.

About the world

What is time?
A written reading and its caption

Reading

10:30

Added caption

The time of the event.

“10:30” gives a clock reading. The caption “the time of the event” connects that reading to an event; the digits alone do not establish the connection.

Information about the clock, date and how the reading was recorded can support it. Those details make the claim more specific and easier to check. The written reading remains a record of time.

What happens after death?
Two written answers to compare

One answer

Nothing.

Another answer

Another life.

“Nothing” and “another life” offer different answers. Writing either one does not establish what will happen. Discussing a particular answer requires its sources, assumptions and reasoning.

Those grounds can be examined while keeping a belief, an argument and the conclusion it supports distinct. The fact that these answers are written does not give Beforeword a further answer about the future.

Does God exist?
Opposing written claims

One claim

God exists.

Another claim

God does not exist.

“God exists” and “God does not exist” are opposing claims. Neither is established by the wording alone. A particular argument can be examined through its premises, sources and steps to the conclusion.

An account of faith and a proof may play different roles in that discussion. “Proof” does not replace the argument, and “faith” does not contain a person’s whole account. Beforeword applies the same questions to both claims without deciding the answer in advance.

Are we living in a simulation?
A claim to examine

Written claim

We live in a simulation.

Term introduced

simulation

“We live in a simulation” offers an account of the world. Examining it needs a particular argument: its assumptions, the information supplied and the steps leading to the conclusion.

“Program,” “creator” and “a world outside” extend the account. A more detailed story is not additional evidence simply because it introduces more terms. The linked discussion provides an argument to examine; the speaker’s authority does not replace its grounds.

Elon Musk on simulation · Code Conference 2016 (video)

Science and other explanations

What about mathematics?
An expression and the reading assigned to it

Expression

2 + 2 = 4

Reading used

“+” means addition here; “=” states equality between the two sides.

In “2 + 2 = 4,” the signs are used under arithmetic rules. Those rules and the calculation steps allow the result to be checked. A number’s notation and an explanation of the calculation remain distinct parts of the analysis.

“Checked by a program” can be supported with the input, execution conditions and result. That gives grounds for reporting the check. A formula, proof or report does not perform the action it describes merely by being written.

What is being added in “2 + two”?
An arithmetic example written for this page

Starting expression

2 + two

Instructions

Replace “two” with “2”. Use “+” for integer addition.

Written steps

2 + 2 = 4

The example contains the written forms “2” and “two”. The arithmetic reading treats them as two ways to write the same number. That connection is stated in the explanation; the written forms remain different. The example then specifies a replacement and a rule for using “+”.

The displayed steps end with “4” as the result under those instructions. “Numbers”, “symbols” or “written forms” would offer different answers to “what is being added?” Explaining one requires showing how the terms are used in the task. The explanation of the calculation remains writing.

If the rules are known, is the conclusion already known?
A short derivation using integer arithmetic

Starting equation

x + 2 = 5

Allowed step

Subtract 2 from both sides.

Result

x = 3

“The rules are known” reports knowledge of the rules. “The conclusion is already known” makes a claim about the conclusion. Inserting “therefore” does not show how the conclusion was obtained. A worked example can supply the starting expression, the rule and its application.

Here, “allowed step” refers to the stated operation, and “result” to the expression reached. The label “theorem” does not replace the statement or its proof. Changed rules or premises would need to be shown too. These details explain the derivation; they remain a written account of it.

What exactly makes a solution “fast”?
Example counts · no timing data

Method A

10 comparisons

Method B

100 comparisons

Method A uses 10 comparisons and Method B uses 100. These counts support a comparison of the stated operations: A uses fewer comparisons. No execution times are supplied.

Calling A faster in elapsed time requires measurements under comparable conditions. Comparisons may take different amounts of time, and other operations may also be involved. Name the measure directly: fewer comparisons or less measured time. The word “faster” does not choose the measure by itself.

How is the label “prime” applied?
Applying the stated definition

5

Positive integer divisors: 1, 5. Label: prime.

6

Positive integer divisors: 1, 2, 3, 6. Label: not prime.

The arithmetic definition used here calls an integer “prime” when it is greater than 1 and has exactly two positive integer divisors: 1 and itself. A positive integer counts as a divisor when dividing the number being tested by it gives an integer result with no remainder.

The example applies those written conditions to “5” and “6”. It shows the lists used to assign the labels. “Prime” names the outcome of applying the definition; its letters are not found inside the digits. The linked definition is another written record of the term’s use, alongside this explanation.

The written definition of “prime number”: NIST DLMF, §27.1

What about physics and measurement?
A reading, its caption and an assessment

Written reading

20 °C

Caption

Temperature in the room.

Added assessment

The room is warm.

Connecting “20 °C” to the chosen room needs information about where, when and with which instrument the measurement was taken. The caption states the connection; the data make it possible to check.

“The room is warm” adds an assessment. It needs an account of what counts as warm here and why. The reading, measurement conditions and assessment can be related while remaining distinct claims.

What about chemistry and substances?
Entries in an example report

Item described

Sample A

Name assigned

water

Formula recorded

H₂O

The constructed report names Sample A as water and records H₂O beside it. Checking that description needs the test conditions, results and the method connecting them to the conclusion about composition.

A formula can accurately describe a composition without becoming the sample. If a result is called confirmed, specify the check performed and what it confirms. Details about molecular structure extend the explanation; they do not replace the particular test data.

What about biology and being human?
A form and two added statements

Form entry

Species: human.

Identification

This is who I am.

Demand

You must identify with this description.

The form uses “human” as a classification. Features and a rule can explain why the label was selected. “This is who I am” adds identification, and “You must identify with this description” adds a demand. Grounds for the classification do not by themselves justify that demand.

Beforeword proposes reconsidering such requirements without first demanding a correctly named refusal, an explanation or a replacement description. If coercion is reported, preserve the exact words and consequences. The biological use of a term can be examined separately from an obligation to identify with it.

Why does a horoscope sound like it is about me?
A horoscope description and a response

Horoscope wording

You hide your feelings.

Added reading

That’s exactly like me.

The example places “You hide your feelings” beside “That’s exactly like me.” The second line reports recognition of the description. It does not yet show how the horoscope produced that description or whether the same method supports other claims.

A specific occasion can help explain why the phrase seems to fit. A claim about someone’s character as a whole or their future needs further grounds. Recognizing a description and confirming a prediction are different questions; the two lines shown here do not settle the second.

Appearance

Theme
Text size

The words we are taught to use about ourselves and the world.