Letters to researchers.

24 letters from Kirill Shebetov (Beforeword) asking what supports claims about understanding, experience and knowledge. Each page contains the wording discussed, the letter and the published correspondence record.

beforeword · Letters published by their author

What in a text supports a claim that someone understands, feels pain or knows something?

Letters addressing specific wording in articles, books and talks. English texts, Russian translations and the available correspondence record.

24 lettersFull texts availableNo replies published yet

Why publish these letters?

The letters ask what supports particular steps: from identical words to a judgment of sincerity; from a prediction result to understanding; from a model description to an attribution of pain.

A public record lets readers compare the wording, beforeword’s question and any published reply. Definitions, criteria and explanations—including those proposed by beforeword—are also part of the examination.

An example from the letter to Amanda Askell
Source: human
“I believe this.”
Source: AI
“I believe this.”

The sentence stays the same. The source label changes. What grounds support a judgment of sincerity in each case?

Read the letter

A starting point

Three ways into the question

All letters 24

  • Amanda Askell

    What changes in a judgment of sincerity when only the source label changes?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • Chris Olah

    What supports each claim in an explanation of a model’s behavior?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • Murray Shanahan

    What supports different readings of “I believe this” from a human and an AI?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • David Chalmers

    What supports reading a written sentence as a report about consciousness?

    Consciousness and experienceSent · no reply published
  • Yoshua Bengio

    What supports admitting a written record as an observation for AI training?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • Geoffrey Hinton

    What supports saying that two formulations “say the same thing”?

    Consciousness and experienceSent · no reply published
  • Ilya Sutskever

    What supports reading successful prediction as evidence of understanding?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • Yann LeCun

    What supports reading action-recognition results as progress toward understanding the world?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • Demis Hassabis

    What justifies reading model output as an account of its reasoning?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • Judea Pearl

    What supports reading an experimental report as evidence for a causal assumption?

    Explanation and groundsSent · no reply published
  • Douglas Hofstadter

    What supports treating two instances of a pattern as the same self?

    Consciousness and experienceSent · no reply published
  • Thomas Metzinger

    What supports reading a report as evidence of “pure awareness”?

    Consciousness and experienceSent · no reply published
  • Wojciech Zaremba

    What supports reading a sentence as an explanation of perception?

    Consciousness and experienceSent · no reply published
  • Stuart Russell

    What supports reading a passage as evidence of a human preference?

    AI and model evaluationSent · no reply published
  • Steven Pinker

    What supports attributing the same idea to two people?

    Language and readingSent · no reply published
  • Robert Brandom

    What supports treating a writer as committed to justifying a claim?

    Language and readingSent · no reply published
  • Michael Tomasello

    What supports attributing mutual knowledge in a shared viewing task?

    Language and readingSent · no reply published
  • David Deutsch

    What distinguishes changing the words from changing the explanation?

    Explanation and groundsSent · no reply published
  • Andy Clark

    What warrants calling a revision of text a correction of thought?

    Language and readingSent · no reply published
  • Dan Sperber

    What is added to the wording when inferring what the writer meant?

    Language and readingSent · no reply published
  • Timothy Williamson

    What supports saying that a reader knows a claim is true?

    Explanation and groundsSent · no reply published
  • Michael Levin

    What supports describing tissue’s bioelectrical state as memory of the body’s shape?

    Explanation and groundsSent · no reply published
  • Nick Bostrom

    What supports the move from described behavior to an attribution of experienced pain?

    Consciousness and experienceSent · no reply published
  • Joscha Bach

    What claim favors a consciousness interpretation over an alternative explanation?

    Explanation and groundsSent · no reply published
How the letters are published and what the statuses mean

The author is publishing sent letters about specific wording in articles, books and talks. Publication does not imply that a recipient participates in the project or agrees with beforeword.

The English texts are transcribed from screenshots supplied by the author. Screen line breaks are joined into paragraphs, and overlapping passages between images are included once. Wording and punctuation are retained; Russian translations and beforeword introductions are labeled separately.

Dates and addresses are limited to what the supplied materials show. Where a header shows only “Friday” or hides an additional recipient, the letter page says so. Sending, receipt, forwarding and a substantive reply are different records.

No replies have been published in this collection yet. This status does not mean agreement, rejection or an inability to object. beforeword’s own wording and proposed grounds remain open to the same examination.

Appearance

Theme
Text size

The words we are taught to use about ourselves and the world.